People Are Talking: The Cripple of Inishmaan
Posted: 3/10/11 -- 12:00 am
by Sara Billmann
Tell us what you thought! This is the place to comment on the performance, and talk to other people about what you saw and heard. Don’t forget to click the option to be notified when new comments are posted.
Sara Billmann has served as UMS's Director of Marketing & Communications since 1996. A former UMS intern, she celebrates her 20th UMS season this year.






















about 4 days ago
about 7 days ago


























































This show is WONDERFUL!! Don’t miss it!
Outstanding acting, humor-filled script – it is an outstanding night of theater!
Tim Grimes
We’re really curious to know what others thought of the production last night. Personally, I find McDonagh’s work to be brilliantly constructed, and I always leave one of his productions feeling like I’ve been on a huge roller-coaster ride that has whipped me from one emotional extreme to another (and while I hate roller-coasters, I love that experience in the theater). How can we be laughing at such cruelty? And yet the show, while incredibly sad, is also very funny. So tell us what you thought — the good, the bad, and the ugly. What are you thinking about “the morning after”?
Sara Billmann
Really funny play, darkly witty. The cast were excellent, the timing and delivery, everything was just spot-on. Interesting set design, as well.
Shaun Manning
This was a great show! The acting was wonderful and I find myself still thinking about the story line. Thanks for bringing it to town, UMS!
Libby
Here’s AnnArbor.com’s review of the play: http://www.annarbor.com/entertainment/review-the-cripple-of-inishmaan/
Bob Needham
Opening night of The Cripple… was one of the worst theatrical experiences we have ever had! Our seats were in the first row center of the balcony, but for the whole first half we could neither hear nor understand most of what was said. Because there were many empty seats downstairs, we moved to a fine location for the second half; the problem didn’t go away. Even though we could hear more, we couldn’t understand much more than previously. We have been to Irish plays in Ireland, but never had so much trouble. The 3 women were especially hard to follow, but from even the others we caught some words but often couldn’t get the point. It might as well be in Gaelic!
Wallace & Diane Pretzer
It is a fascinating play, lean and spare in execution but twisty and tormented on the inside. Everyone with a personal pain, each with their own, personal way of trying to overcome (or repress) it. Thought-provoking, and a hoot at the same time!
Jeff MacKie Mason
wonderful play. so glad i was able to see it and bring my friends as well. poignantly funny. sharp.
Arthur
the show was awesome..! im definitely coming back again
Dharashree
After the idiosyncratically brilliant screenplay of *In Bruges,* I expected much, perhaps too much… but even without those expectations, I would respond to this production with ambivalence, at best. In fact I came close to walking out of it in the first act, which I cannot be said to consider very often at a major play production. True, the dark, mean comedy is good, but is it enough to carry a play? When it worked best it seemed to be working as a series of skits–not enough to merit an international tour. And the humor was based on such broad, almost embarrassing self-exoticization, I found it barely tolerable. I really am interested in knowing whether I’m really so alone in finding the whole thing more distasteful than anything else. Sorry.
Buzzaa
I’m sorry to say I mostly agree with you! We DID walk out at intermission – not in any kind of ranting, angry way but just because we were disappointed and not willing to end our evening with it. I think my expectations were too high – UMS has spoiled us wonderfully with Royal Shakespeare Company and the Abbey Theatre in recent years. I thought this production was fine for a collegiate level performance, but we spent $100 on it! The script lacked any real wit or wisdom – it did have what could be called charming “Irish-isms” in it, but it wasn’t truly ‘biting’ or even funny. I wish them well on their tour, I’m glad audiences are responding better than me, but I am a bit mystified about it.
Mary
Buzzaa is not alone. The play was self-exoticizing, touched on about every Irish stereotype, with emphasis on cruelty (and I don’t much enjoy mean comedy anyway). Well, maybe it did chip away at the one stereotype: that of a friendly Irishman who deep down enjoys and loves the hardscrabble life… But that did not seem to be one of the points the play was making.
rw
I learned last night that you can’t judge a play by the script.
Having read the play before, I found its dramatization funny, sad, uncomfortable and finally quite satisfying. No doubt that is due to the fine acting and directing.
The only critique might be that the audience in the back and balcony may not have heard the play as well as I did in front.
More projection might be necessary. Otherwise congratulations for a bleak theme well told.
Ernestine McGlynn
Delightfully funny well acted theater. Do not miss this one!!
Ann Wilhite
This play certainly tests your patience! The pauses and repetitions of phrase and ideas reflect the slow pace of life in a remote Irish village. I struggled at the beginning but then enjoyed the play more and more as I accepted the agonizing slow pace of events and allowed the play to unfold at its own pace. The relationships are blunt and brutal. Nothing is politically correct. I expected more digs at the English than were delivered. I didn’t have any problems understanding what was said despite some thick accents and local Irish expressions. It’s the sort of play that provokes discussion so worth catching while it’s here. In full disclosure, I’m on the UMS Board however this is my first posting to the UMS Lobby.
David Canter
There is much laughter from the audience. The play is written to elicit laughs. But not everybody laughs, and if they do, it’s an awkward, embarrassed, and uncomfortable laugh. This is not a comedy. We’re looking into a community whose members are beastly to each other, self-centered, desperate, and pitiable. The crippled boy softens them – but only temporarily. Only his parents are kind and loving. But they are dead. What’s to laugh at here?
The point is that, if you don’t assume that this is a TV comedy, then you’re bound to feel uncomfortable.
And then, if you think about that, you wonder what the point is, what the playwright was up to.
Excellent production, fine acting, flawed play.
Many speeches were hard to make out.
playgoer
The three of us thoroughly enjoyed the production–the acting, the staging, and the dialogue. The play provoked much discussion among us on the way home. However, the audio needed more volume and the accents were difficult for our ears at times. The script certainly made the point that some of us are handicapped on the outside and and many on the inside. Thanks for offering it to the community.
South Lyon
If you think you’re prescient, you’re in for a surprise. If you think you can manage your emotions in public, make sure you sit next to people you know. If you think you’ve perfected the art of the penetrating, guttural insult, bring your notebook. The only excuse you should have for missing The Cripple of Inishmaan tonight or tomorrow is a funeral for which you are the honoree! -Clayton
Clayton Wilhite
This is a fantastic play. Beautifully acted, bringing the audience right up on the stage with them. Reading the play makes a big difference because the accents and phrasing is a bit challenging. The play is funny, sad, heartwarming – completely human.
DON’T MISS IT!
Prue Rosenthal
I found this production of “Cripple” strongly acted from top to bottom. The actor who played CrippleBilly moved beautifully, and as with “Elephant Man,” was able to show the beauty of the person trapped inside a misshapen body. The store-setting looked hastily and cheaply painted to me, but that was my only reservation. Thanks to UMS for bringing this play and company for us to see in Ann Arbor.
Leigh Woods
We also nearly left at intermission, only stayed to the end because we were meeting our daughter, a U. of M. freshman, for dinner. The Saturday Night Live cast could have done this in five minutes and actually been funny. What a waste of time and money.
Angela Kennedy
Loved this play! So funny! The acting was spot on and the progression of the play really gives an extra feel of the rural life.
Audrey
that is awesome
czzj378
We were delighted with “Cripple…” It helped that we had attended the lecture/scene-demonstration at the Library the Wed. eve before, given by Martin Walsh, and one of the directors of the play (I don’t remember her name). We learned a bit about the background of the play and watched a bit of “Man from Aran” which was the movie (fil-um) at the center of the play. We are just so happy to live in Ann Arbor where treasures such as this are presented on a regular basis.
Mary Crandall
I found this play to be entertaining and uplifting. The writing and acting, and directing too I guess, were top-notch. (I don’t know how to tell when good acting is due to good directing.) All the actors delivered their lines with wonderful timing and inflection. The accents and the local viewpoints were entertaining and I think it was obvious that the characters were not as simple as they appeared to be.
I was in the back of the balcony and the volume of the voices was adequate, but just.
Another delightful presentation in our humble city.
Richard Hausman
I know I’m a little late in leaving a comment but the memories are still fresh. I’m so glad UMS brought theater like this to Ann Arbor. Good to see something other than Kafka and Shakespeare. There is a whole world out there that I can’t afford to visit…Well no, we get to Chicago and Guthrie in Minneapolis…just can’t vault across the Atlantic like we did in our 20′s.
Robert Kinsey
26
Share